Elsewhere · Case studies, research and news

It's already happening.

People in other places have already turned the straw that would have been burned into food, a living and better soil. Here is what we found, 10 stories from 4 countries, set out along the problem Khoombi works on. Each one links to its source and says plainly where the evidence is thin.

1 of 5

Straw is burned

After the rice harvest the field has to be cleared quickly, and fire is the quickest and cheapest way. Every autumn, thousands of fields burn within a few weeks.

16,714

likely crop-residue fires seen by satellite across Punjab, 1 October to 9 November 2026

Pakistan Air Quality Initiative, via Dawn

2 of 5

Smoke over the cities

The smoke drifts into the cities and joins traffic fumes and burning rubbish. Still winter air holds it there, over the people who breathe it.

8×

Lahore's fine-particle pollution against the WHO guideline, autumn 2026. Crop burning's share: between 4% and a third, depending on the study.

Dawn; Urban Unit emissions inventory

3 of 5

Straw grows mushrooms

Oyster mushrooms grow on straw, packed in a bag and kept in a dark corner. The paddy straw that gets burned is one of the best things to grow them on.

+10%

more oyster mushrooms on rice straw than on wheat straw, grown side by side

Zhang, Li & Fadel, 2002

4 of 5

Food and a living

A family eats what it grows and sells what's left, from a spare room. Across the border in Haryana, one farming block turned this into a living.

100+

mushroom farms run by about 20 small farmers in Israne, Panipat. An officer there reckoned they kept 46,000 tonnes of straw a year from the fire.

Down To Earth, 2015

5 of 5

Back to the soil

After a few harvests the straw is spent. It crumbles into compost and goes back to the fields it came from, and the loop closes.

2 years

of trials in rice paddies, where used mushroom straw added with fertiliser raised harvests. Check what it was grown on: it can carry heavy metals.

Plants, 2024

Fig. 1Every story, sorted by the link it speaks to. Choose a link to see only its stories.
News
Punjab, Pakistan
Nov 2026

16,714 fires in six weeks

Satellites picked up 16,714 likely crop-residue fires across Punjab between 1 October and 9 November 2026. Over the same weeks, Lahore's air averaged 126 micrograms of fine particles per cubic metre, about eight times the WHO guideline.

Keep in mind: The report, by the Pakistan Air Quality Initiative, says the fires and the smog together don't show how much of the smog the fires caused. Still winter air also traps pollution.

Case study
Israne, Panipat, Haryana, India
2015

A farming block that stopped burning its straw

In Israne block, more than 20 small farmers ran over 100 mushroom farms on paddy straw. The local agriculture officer worked out that this kept about 46,000 tonnes of straw a year from being burned.

Keep in mind: The 46,000 tonnes is the officer's own estimate, from 2015. We haven't found a later check on how the farms are doing.

Research
Lahore, Pakistan
2023

About a third of Lahore's fine-particle pollution

The Punjab government's Urban Unit counted where Lahore's fine-particle pollution comes from, using 2020–21 data. Transport came first at about 35%, crop-residue burning close behind at about 33%, then waste burning at about 29%.

Keep in mind: Other studies put crop burning much lower, some as low as 4%. The share depends on the year, the season and the method. Most agree it is one large cause among several, alongside traffic, weather and smoke from across the border.

Research
Study
2002

Rice straw grows more oyster mushrooms than wheat straw

Grown side by side under the same conditions, oyster mushrooms on rice straw gave about 10% more mushrooms than on wheat straw. The paddy straw Punjab burns is a good thing to grow on.

Keep in mind: One species (Pleurotus sajor-caju), grown without added nutrients. Results vary with how the straw is prepared.

Research
Study
2024

Which straw grows the most

Four straws compared: wheat, maize, faba bean and soybean. The fresh mushroom harvest ranged from 114% of the straw's dry weight on maize to 58% on wheat. Maize stalks, also common in Pakistan, did best.

Keep in mind: Wheat straw came last here, and rice straw wasn't tested. It still grows mushrooms well; adding bran usually helps.

News
Ludhiana, Punjab, India
Oct 2023

A winter course with a reason not to burn

Punjab Agricultural University ran a five-day winter mushroom course for 32 growers. Its experts urged farmers not to burn paddy straw, and to use it for mushrooms, cardboard or biogas instead.

Case study
Can Tho, Vietnam
2025

A cooperative that grows on its own rice straw

At the Tien Thuan cooperative in the Mekong Delta, farmers grow straw mushrooms on rolls of rice straw, 750–900 kg a crop from 500–600 rolls, and turn what's left into compost. Training there led to five small straw businesses that created jobs and raised incomes beyond rice alone.

Keep in mind: No income figures were published, and two reports on the same cooperative give different production numbers.

Case study
Zimbabwe
Since 1998

Mushrooms for people with no land

Chido Govera was orphaned at seven. At eleven she learned to grow oyster mushrooms on maize stalks at Africa University, and the harvests supported her family. Through her Future of Hope Foundation she now teaches orphans and girls, because mushrooms need so little space that no land is needed.

Keep in mind: This is drawn from an encyclopedia entry and press stories, not from her foundation's own reports.

Case study
Charsadda, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan
Nov 2020

Tobacco-growing families try mushrooms

In Haider Kaley, 20 women from tobacco-growing families took a four-day mushroom course, part of a pilot for 30 women and 30 men run by Helvetas with Khyber Mushroom Farm. The plan expected about Rs 500 from a bag in a season, against roughly Rs 87 to set it up.

Keep in mind: Those are expectations, not results. Families said they would carry on only if the pilot paid, and we haven't found what happened next.

Research
Study
2024

What's left after growing feeds the next crop

A two-year field study in rice paddies found that the used straw from mushroom growing, added with fertiliser, raised harvests and improved the soil.

Keep in mind: The same study warns that used straw can carry heavy metals that build up in soil over time, so it depends on what the mushrooms were grown on.

What's missing

Few results from Pakistan, so far

We found trainings and pilots in Pakistan, but almost nothing published about what happened afterwards: how much people grew, ate and earned, and whether they kept going. That gap is a large part of why Khoombi exists.

If you have grown mushrooms on straw here, or know of a project, a study or a news story that belongs on this page, we would like to hear about it.

Tell us about one →Try it at home →Read the idea →